43.2 The Drop Radio
  • HOME
  • DROP LIBRARY
  • DROP PACKAGES
  • LIVE ON AIR!
    • SHOW ARCHIVES
    • SHOW PLAYLISTS
  • VIBE SUITES
    • INDIGENOUS FLUTE
    • LOVER'S ROCK (LOVE SONGS)
    • THE HIGH ROAD (ALTERNATIVE)
    • JAMMIN' REBEL (REGGAE)
    • MIMOSA (JAZZ)
    • THE BASEMENT (RAP)
    • NEON VALLEY (POP / RNB)
    • THE MIDNIGHT HOUR (BEDROOM)
    • EBONY EYEZ (SOUL RNB)
    • LET'S COOL ONE (CHILL MIX)
    • THE DROP ZONE (DOPE DROP MIX)
    • B.O.B IS BANGIN'
  • WHAT IS 432HZ?
  • ARTISTS LOUNGE
  • DROP NETWORKS
    • DROP ARTISTS NETWORK
    • FOOD TRUCK DROP NETWORK
  • DROP ALBUMS
  • ADVERTISE

THE DROP IS KNOWLEDGE
POWER
ORGANIC 432 FREQUENCY

432hz, the natural vibration of the Earth is mathematically consistent with Love. Vibrate in our "Vibe Suites" and "Artists Lounge" featuring the hottest indie artists and producers in the world. Stay tuned... our live 43.2 The Drop Radio shows are almost back!

SUBSCRIBE FOR FREE TO DROP NATION VIP

THE RACIST HISTORY OF PETER PAN'S INDIAN TRIBE

12/2/2014

2 Comments

 
Picture
Princess Tiger Lily, Indian Chief and Peter Pan as depicted in the 1953 film.
Even in the early 20th century, though, critics saw Tiger Lily and her fellow "Picaninnies" as caricatures. 
When Peter Pan opened in 1904, it was an instant hit, "from beginning to end a thing of pure delight," wrote The Times of London that December. Part of that delight was Neverland—a place where all the imaginings of the Darling children came to life.

Peter Pan's creator, J.M. Barrie, described Neverland as island of "coral reefs and rakish-looking craft in the offing, and savages and lonely lairs, and gnomes who are mostly tailors, and caves through which a river runs, and princes with six elder brothers...and one very small old lady with a hooked nose." This was the cast of characters that populated turn-of-the-century playtime in Britain, and in the play, as one New York Times reviewer wrote in 1905, "Mr. Barrie presents not the pirate or Indian of grown-up fiction but the creations seen by childish eyes."

In practice, that meant portraying the fierce tribe that lives on Neverland in a way that even in the early 20th-century looked like a caricature. As The Times of London wrote:

"...the Never-Never-Land is peopled by Red Indians and Pirates, who lose no time in showing us that they know how to 'behave as sich.' [sic] The Red Indians always lay their ear to the ground, then give vent to unearthly yells, and prepare for scalping somebody—a Pirate, for choice."

At the time, this portrayal wasn't controversial. But while much of Barrie's original work is just as delightful today as 110 years ago, Tiger Lily and her tribe have become a problem for contemporary productions. There's no real reason for a tribe of Native Americans —"not be confused with the softer-hearted Delawares or the Hurons," Barrie wrote—to live on Neverland, where they are impossible to excise from the story. But it's almost as impossible to depict them in a way that's not offensive.

In the play, Peter refers to the tribe as "piccaninny warriors," and in Peter & Wendy (Barrie's book-long adaptation of the story, published in 1911), they are introduced as the "Piccaninny tribe"—a blanket stand-in for "others" of all stripes, from Aboriginal populations in Australia to descendants of slaves in the United States. Barrie's tribespeople communicate in pidgin; the braves have lines like "Ugh, ugh, wah!" Tiger Lily is slightly more loquacious; she'll say things like "Peter Pan save me, me his velly nice friend. Me no let pirates hurt him." They call Peter "the great white father"—the name that Barrie had originally chosen for the entire play. A tom-tom pounded in victory is a key plot point.

"It was a popular fantasy trope," says Anne Hiebert Alton, a professor of English at Central Michigan University and the editor of a scholarly edition of Peter Pan. "Barrie was telling the story in the very early 1900s, and so part of it, I think, was: this was a good story, this'll stage well. He was very Victorian—and that's the age when British people were still proud to brag that the sun never set on the British empire."

Peter Pan grew from Barrie's relationship with a family of boys, the Llewelyn Davies brothers, and the games they used to play. In the biography J.M. Barrie and the Lost Boys, the writer and filmmaker Andrew Birkin suggests that theirs was "a world of pirates, Indians and 'wrecked islands'"—a sort of mish-mash of Victorian adventure stories. Barrie likely would have been influenced by James Fenimore Cooper's stories, Alton says; he also loved "penny dreadfuls"—trashy adventure novels. Birkin writes that one book in particular, The Coral Island, provided the outline for the adventures that Barrie created for the Llewelyn Davies boys. The book does have "natives" in it: shipwrecked on an island, the white heroes come upon two groups of native people, one in pursuit of another. When they see the pursuers threaten to kill a woman and her children, the heroes come to the rescue; they befriend the tribe they've saved and, in particular, the chief's beautiful daughter. It's not so unlike how Peter and Tiger Lily become friends—when he saves her from doom at the hands of Captain Hook's pirates.  

However the tribe ended up in Peter Pan, Barrie's work has not been scrutinized as closely as the portrayals of native people in children's books written a generation later--Mary Poppins, for instance, or A Little House on the Prairie--which were subject to more serious criticism, both popular and academic.

First written in 1934 (more than 20 years after Barrie published Peter & Wendy), Mary Poppins included a chapter in which the famous nanny takes her charges to visit the four points of the compass, where they meet, in author P.L. Travers' words, "a mandarin in the East, an Indian in the West, an Eskimo in the North, and blacks in the South who speak in a pickaninny language." By the 1980s, this chapter was considered so objectionable that the San Francisco public library took the book off the shelves; Travers rewrote the chapter to feature "a panda, dolphin, polar bear, and macaw."

Some books were so obviously offensive that they were altered almost immediately: Agatha Christie's And Then There Were None was first published in Britain in 1935 as Ten Little Niggers. The title was changed in 1940, for the first American edition. And while Laura Ingalls Wilder’s A Little House on the Prairie, first published in 1935, has never been revised, there's an extensive body of scholarly criticism examining the portrayal of the Osage people the Ingalls family encounters as a frightening "other."

By contrast, Peter Pan has gotten off rather lightly. Occasionally the play's content derails a performance—in 1994, one Long Island school canceled a planned production— but there's little critical academic work focused on the tribe that Barrie created. And the original text still stands unrevised.

"Peter Pan is really weird in this sense, because it's protected," Alton says. Barrie gifted the copyright to the Great Osmond Street Hospital for Children, in London, and when the copyright expired in 1987, the British Parliament passed a special extension that gave the hospital the rights to receive royalties from stage productions, radio broadcasts, e-books and other adaptations, in perpetuity.

For years, the hospital kept tight control over who used Peter Pan and how. "Nobody could touch it," Alton says. In the United Kingdom, anyone adapting the story or anyone performing it—even schools—still has to apply to the hospital for a license.

The earlier adaptations that were approved, though, did not do much to update Barrie's portrayal of native people. If anything, the 1953 Disney movie doubled-down on racial stereotypes; one of the film's songs is "What Made the Red Man Red." 
The heralded 1954 musical (with a completely different song list from the Disney movie) still had the tribe running around the stage saying "Ugga-wugga-wigwam." "Sondra Lee, as Tiger Lily, the Indian maid, is uproarious," Brooks Atkinson, then nearing the end of his long term as the New York Times' theater critic, wrote. "She dances and acts a sort of gutter Indian with a city accent that is mocking and comical." The 1960 televised version of the musical became a stalwart of NBC's programming for decades to come. 
More recently, though, directors who take on Peter Pan have tried to update these ideas, a tiny bit. Hook, the 1991 Robert Zemeckis movie, leaves the tribe out altogether. When the British director Tim Carroll staged Peter Pan for the Stratford Festival in 2010, he turned the tribe into Amazons.

"The role of the Indians in the play is to be both exotic and a bit savage," he wrote in an email. "But the use of the term (and the stereotyped language) could only cause offense to a North American audience. It seemed to me that 'Amazons' was a neat way of killing two birds with one stone: as mythic warriors they satisfied the 'exotic and savage' criterion; but it also allowed me to cast a group of women."

2015's Pan, a film that imagines Peter's first years in Neverland as an orphan kidnapped by pirates and forced to work in a mine, made a similar choice. The film features Mara Rooney as Tiger Lily but dresses her tribe in a sort of outlandishly bright array of pinks, purples, browns and bright blues that manages to be fantastic enough that no one would ever confuse this tribe with an American Indian tribe.

NBC's 2014 version of the 1954 musical is going in the opposite direction, in search of something like authenticity. Unknown actress Alanna Saunders, whose paternal heritage has distant ties to the Cherokee nation, will play Tiger Lily, and the song "Ugg-a-Wugg" was updated to include actual Native American phrases. Perhaps these changes will keep today's directors from looking, in another hundred years, like purveyors of crude racial stereotypes; perhaps they'll seem just as clumsy as Barrie's original conception of the tribe's relationship to Peter—"We redskins — you the great white father."

source: smithsonian.com
By Sarah Laskow
2 Comments
Shondra
12/2/2014 08:40:48 am

No "Indian" tribe in '91 only reveals the sinister plot behind many films especially cartoons.

Reply
rob
12/2/2014 03:14:01 pm

yes cartoons are very dangerous

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    ENJOY YOUR 432 HZ
    "SOUL RNB" VIBE SUITE

    EBONY EYEZ

    Picture
    Click to enter "Ebony Eyez"

    SUPPORT DROP NATION!

    Picture
    SUPPORT DROP NATION
    PAYPAL 4 THE DROP

    DROP LIBRARY

    Picture
    ENTER DROP LIBRARY

    ROCK DA DROP

    ORDER YOUR DROP NATION SHIRT TODAY!
    Picture
    Picture
    Sizes

    "YES U DO" 
    THE FREQUENCY ANTHEM
    Download Free Now

    SUBSCRIBE FOR FREE TO JOIN DROP NATION VIP!


    Join today and receive your favorite 5 songs re-tuned to 432hz every month! For a limited time only!

    drop tuner

    Upload up to 50 of your favorite songs every month and we'll send them back in 432hz Swag Frequency!
    email us to get started today...
    music@432thedrop.com
    Swag Frequency
    Email

    DAILY DROP

    HOW TO GET STARTED TODAY WITH OUR NEW 432 HERTZ DROP TUNER SERVICE! FREE!!!
    Daily Drop Archives

    LET US FIND THE TRUTH

    VIRTUAL PUBLIC LIBRARY
    Picture
    LETUSFINDTHETRUTH

    LATEST LIVE ON-AIR SHOWS

    TDR | THE BOILING POINT
    Picture

    Click button below to open live shows in a separate browser for uninterrupted streaming.
    SHOW ARCHIVES

    WHO GOT THE DROP? 
    HIRAM ART


    DONATE TO FIGHT SICKLE CELL

    Picture
    Donate to Camp Crescent Moon today and help our children fight Sickle Cell
    Donate Today!

    Categories

    All
    420 Drop
    432 Drop
    432 Live Radio Shows
    #ADD Drop
    Album Drop
    Alden Davis
    Animal Drop
    Art Drop
    Arthur Scott Jr
    Artists Lounge
    Book Drop
    Brandy Brim Show
    Bro Sanchez Tv
    Business Drop
    Chef Ahki
    Classic Drop
    Community Drop
    Compare 432 Vs 440
    Cool Drop
    Cop Drop
    Cynthia G
    Daily Drop
    Daughter Of Israel
    Drop Albums
    Drop Artist Battles
    Drop Artist Features
    Drop Artists
    Drop Artist Vids
    Drop Beats
    Drop Exclusive
    Drop Freestyle
    Drop Interviews
    Drop Kicks
    Drop Library
    Drop Nation
    Drop Or Die
    Drop Poetry
    Drop Producer Battles
    Drop Producer Features
    Drop Tracks
    Drop Vidz
    Drop Whips
    Drop Writers
    Dry Bones Rising
    Education Drop
    Ernest Anderson
    Faith Drop
    Fashion Drop
    Fight Drop
    Film/tv Drop
    Fitness Drop
    Flat Drop
    Food Drop
    Food Truck Drop
    Francisco
    Funny Drop
    Galactic Drop
    Gamer Drop
    Geoshifter
    Getting To Root Of It All
    Grimnasty Tv
    Hallway Ch
    Health Drop
    Hiram Art
    Historic Drop
    Hood2hood1000
    Hurt Beezy
    Ig45n2
    Immanuel Hizkiyah
    Industry Drop
    Infinite Waters
    Irvin Reed
    J Stew
    Kaptain Kush
    Kiddie Drop
    King Drane
    King Drop
    Kotaku
    Legal Drop
    Let Us Find The Truth
    Lexwill
    Life Drop
    Live Drop
    Lord Of The Universe13
    Madison Smilez
    Ma Truth
    Medicine Man
    Misc Drop
    M Mitchell
    Money Drop
    Multi Drop
    Mw Smith
    Mz Dee And Copper Color Awakenig
    Naija Drop
    Negrito Grande
    News Drop
    Oktoba Skorpio
    Phi Yah
    Photo Drop
    Political Drop
    Prof Spira
    Racing Drop
    Rara The Great
    Real Spill
    Rest In Power
    Rfg Chosen One
    Scattered Yasharal Views
    Science Drop
    Secret Drop
    Seed Drop
    Short Film Drop
    Sister Drop
    Sneaker Drop
    Space Drop
    SPORTS DROP
    Style Drop
    Styles By Nina
    Suit Up
    Survival Drop
    Tayla Andre
    Tbt Drop
    Teachmetobepriestly
    TECH DROP
    Thee Original American
    Tmel Ra Smith Bey
    Top Drop
    Tree Drop
    Truthunveiled777
    Tyrone St
    Underwater Drop
    Unidentified Drop
    Uno Onthebeatz
    Wake Up With Mr Pete
    War Drop
    Watch Drop
    Weather Drop
    Wildlife Drop
    Winnifer Holcolb
    Word Drop
    World Drop
    Wtf Drop
    Yahunathon


    ENJOY our latest DROP ARTIST and PRODUCER features!

    SUPPORT INDIE ARTISTS!

    ARTIST FEATURES
    PROD. FEATURES

    LAST SHOW'S PLAYLIST ENJOY YOUR 432HZ "SWAG FREQUENCY" EXPERIENCE.
    SHOW PLAYLISTS

    CYMATICS EXPERIMENT
    432HZ VS 440HZ


    WHAT IS 432 HZ?

    Follow @432thedrop

    Picture
    Picture

    The Drop is Cutting Edge Frequency
    The Drop
    is Knowledge
    The Drop is Power!


    DROP QUOTE
    "TRUTH NEVER NEEDS VALIDATION FROM IGNORANCE"
    - DICK GREGORY


    VIBE SUITE

    What vibe suits you?
    Pick your own 432Hz Healthy Music VIBE & enjoy your travels through wonderland...

    DROP FLOW


    LADY'S LOVE


    THE BASEMENT


    MAKE ME WORK IT


    MEDITATE WITH ME


    LET'S GET JAZZY


    Picture

    THE DROPOFF

    Vibrate with King Drop  dropping the latest indie music, drop topics and exclusive interviews!
    LIVE SHOWS RETURNING SOON!!!!!!


    Archives

    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    December 1969

    RSS Feed


Copyright 43.2 The Drop Radio, LLC